Navigating Disclosure of Leadership Transitions in Proxy Statements

Navigating Disclosure of Leadership Transitions in Proxy Statements

Introduction

CEO turnovers were on the upswing in 2025: there were 168 new CEOs in the S&P 1500—the most since 2010—including 59 new CEOs in the S&P 500. A significant number of the departing executives (45% in the S&P 500) had been in their roles for less than five years. (Spencer Stuart, 2025 S&P 1500 CEO Transitions: Behind the CEO Moment, February 2026.)

When a new person assumes the very visible role of public company CEO, investors and proxy advisors want to understand who the new executive is, how and why that person was chosen, and how that person will be compensated. As recent proxies demonstrate, disclosure to address those questions can appear in multiple places.

Leadership letter

Often companies want to announce the arrival of a new CEO at the very beginning of the proxy. For example, PayPal, Intel, Target, Walmart, and Johnson Controls all used a leadership letter to introduce the company’s new CEO, explain why the individual was the right person for the role, and summarize identified priorities.

Message from Our Independent Board Chair
Letter from Your Board Chair
Letter from our Lead Independent Director
Message from our Lead Independent Director
Letter to Shareholders

Proxy summary

Verizon, PayPal, and AIG all flagged the hiring of a new CEO in their proxy summaries, though (appropriately) none provided much detail in this section. Bio-Techne and AIG mentioned leadership transitions in their engagement highlights, but covered the topic again in the Governance section of their proxies, as discussed below.

2025 and First Quarter 2026 Highlights
2026 CEO Transition
Whats New
Leadership Transition

Governance

Companies focus on different aspects of governance when they discuss their executive transitions. For example, PayPal, AIG, and Lumen each describe how their succession planning process contributed to recent successful leadership transitions. Bio-Techne, AIG, and Lumen state that their leadership transitions were discussed during meetings with shareholders, with AIG specifically noting that the proxy includes new disclosure about the subject in response to shareholder interest. Johnson Controls also summarized the company’s transition-related conversations with shareholders, but in the CD&A.

Independent Board Chair and President and Chief Executive Officer Transitions
CEO Succession Planning
CEO and Executive Succession Planning
Stakeholder Engagement
Shareholder Engagement
By the Numbers Shareholder Engagement in 2025
Fiscal 2025 Shareholder Engagement

Finally, AIG, Target, and Johnson Controls all explain that the Board used the occasion of a CEO transition to re-evaluate and revise its leadership structure. At AIG and Target, the outgoing Chairman & CEO moved into an Executive Chair role and the new CEO joined the Board as a regular member. Johnson Controls, which had formerly had a combined Chairman & CEO, elected an independent Chair to support the new CEO. According to research by Spencer Stuart, 8% of the newly-appointed S&P 1500 CEOs also became Board Chair in 2025, while 25% of the boards welcoming a new CEO appointed an executive chair (often but not always the outgoing CEO). Verizon and PayPal reversed this progression by electing sitting directors to serve as CEO.

Board Structure
Board leadership structure
Board Leadership

Compensation Committee letter

 

A letter from the compensation committee can explain the reasoning behind the compensation programs and packages described in the CD&A. This context can be especially helpful when a new executive, particularly a new CEO, joins the company. Intel’s Compensation Committee letter explained that the new CEO’s compensation package was designed to attract him to the role while also addressing previous shareholder feedback. In addition, the letter noted that internal leadership transitions were among the factors that affected how the committee set performance targets.

Intel’s Compensation Committee letter explained that the new CEO’s compensation package was designed to attract him to the role while also addressing previous shareholder feedback. In addition, the letter noted that internal leadership transitions were among the factors that affected how the committee set performance targets.

Compensation Committee Letter

AIG’s Compensation and Management Resources Committee similarly explained that the new CEO’s compensation package was necessary to attract him to the position and that it reflects both shareholder feedback and competitive benchmarking. The committee also described how compensation for the outgoing CEO was adjusted to reflect his new role as Executive Chair.

Letter from the Compensation and Management Resources Committee

Bio-Techne’s Compensation Committee letter focused on their responses to a low say-on-pay vote and a range of shareholder concerns. Among other things, the committee noted that the new CEO’s compensation package was structurally different from the criticized package awarded to his predecessor.

A Message from Our Compensation Committee

CD&A Executive Summary

Aware that a new CEO’s compensation package is a matter of great interest, some companies choose to cover, or at least summarize, the topic at the start of the CD&A.

Target devotes half a page to transition-related compensation decisions, covering the basic points about the compensation packages for the incoming CEO and the outgoing CEO/incoming Executive Chair.

Executive summary

PayPal and AIG both use the CD&A executive summary to describe the new CEO’s compensation in some detail. AIG had a planned, congenial CEO transition, but underscored the need to appropriately compensate the outgoing CEO to “facilitate continuity of leadership.” PayPal describes both the “regular” and “one-time” features of the new CEO’s compensation package, and briefly explains how the terminated CEO and the interim CEO were compensated.

2026 Leadership Transition
Interim President and CEO Compensation
Compensation Discussion and Analysis Executive Summary
Our Leadership Transition

CD&A

By far the most common approach to describing a new CEO’s compensation package is to devote a special section to the subject in the body of the CD&A.

Prologis had a planned transition in which the outgoing CEO became Executive Chair and the incoming CEO was promoted from within. Interestingly, the “2026 Updates” section of the CD&A devotes far more space to the compensation package designed to retain the outgoing CEO than it does to the package awarded to the promoted executive.

2026 Updates

Monro brought in a new CEO and awarded him a compensation package that would make up for compensation he was forfeiting from his previous employer and also address the risk that his tenure would be shortened by a change in control. To put the CEO’s compensation in perspective and emphasize how it was mostly performance-based, the narrative description was followed by an itemized list comparing the CEO’s compensation as reported in the summary compensation table to his realized compensation. A later section of the CD&A summarized the terms of the new CEO’s employment agreement.

CEO Appointment
Fitzsimmons Agreements

The compensation package for Verizon’s new CEO includes many of the same features that were awarded by Monro, including a “make whole” equity award and protection against certain terminations of employment. Notably, since the new CEO was expected to serve only two years, one of his primary responsibilities was “to identify and develop a strong CEO succession candidate.” Verizon provided that the time-vesting conditions of the new CEO’s equity awards would be deemed satisfied when he “facilitated an orderly transition of his duties” to a more permanent executive. There is a brief description of compensation for the outgoing CEO, who remained as a “special advisor.”

Additional compensation actions taken in 2025
Appointment of Mr. Vestberg as Special Advisor
Under the terms of the letter agreement

Lumen had recent transitions in several executive roles, resulting in a range of disclosure. The CD&A explains the ongoing and one-time compensation awarded to a new EVP, the severance arrangements for an outgoing EVP who was involuntarily terminated, and the clawback of a portion of the sign-on bonus awarded to a third EVP who resigned.

Compensation Arrangements Related to Leadership Transition
Severance Compensation Paid to Ashley Haynes Gaspar our Former EVP Chief Revenue Officer

Johnson Controls described the ongoing and one-time compensation awarded to the new CEO, as well as the terms of the company’s employment agreement with the outgoing CEO, who served a few months as Executive Chair and another few months as an advisor.

2025 CEO Leadership Transitions

Thoughts for your 2027 proxy statement

The proxy statement that follows a significant leadership transition should include disclosure that specifically addresses the change. If an executive departure was forced, investors will want to know what the new executive will do differently. If the transition was planned and orderly, it offers a great opportunity to spotlight the board’s succession planning processes. In all cases, investors will want to know how the new executive will be compensated—especially if there have been say-on-pay issues in recent years. Wherever these disclosures appear, make them obvious by using clear headers or other visual clues.

PARTAGER :
logo r1
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.