Executive Succession Planning as an Ongoing Process

Executive Succession Planning as an Ongoing Process

Introduction

In 2025, the average tenure of sitting S&P 500 C-suite leaders was 5.2 years, and 59% of those executives were appointed from within. Those numbers suggest that corporate boards are intently focused on identifying and developing internal talent to ensure that key roles are not left unfilled after a planned or unexpected executive departure. Since investors too are becoming more focused on leadership continuity, we are seeing increasingly more proxy disclosure about succession planning. What was once just a line or two under “board oversight” or “risk management” is now a topic often covered in some detail.

Active board involvement

Many companies emphasize that they don’t just gear up to replace an executive when they know an opening is imminent. Rather, they view succession planning as an ongoing exercise to identify and train potential leaders and to recognize gaps well before there is a position to fill.

Some companies, like Chevron, Allstate, and Conagra, consider succession planning an important topic that merits discussion in letters from leadership at the start of the proxy.

Dear stockholder
Letter from independent directors
Message from our chairman

Most commonly though, companies discuss succession planning in a distinct part of the Governance section of their proxies. Generally speaking, the focus is on the board’s process. For example, Conagra explains that the board recently developed a profile of the ideal future CEO to facilitate long-term planning. Royal Caribbean talks about evaluating executives’ “strengths, contributions, …readiness, and areas for development.” Target describes the different roles of the full board and the compensation committee, with the latter assuming responsibility for “career development for high-potential members of management.” Goldman Sachs notes that the board prioritizes interacting with the various officers in the firm’s leadership pipeline.

succession planning for senior executives
Executive succession planning
Management development and succession planning
Executive succession planning Developing the next generation of leaders

Many companies, such as Broadcom and Freeport-McMoran, emphasize that the board develops both longterm and emergency succession plans, at least with respect to the most senior positions.

Succession planning
Succession planning for senior executives

In most cases, these disclosures appear solely in text. However, Allstate uses a timeline graphic to illustrate the board’s process. Lowes and Minerals Technologies (shown below), and Royal Caribbean, Target, and Goldman Sachs (shown above) also incorporate some graphic elements to organize their disclosures and make them more visually appealing.

Management succession planning and senior leadership development
Boards oversight of executive succession planning
The boards role in succession planning

Focus on internal promotions

Although it is not unusual for boards to determine that the best person to fill an open role is an outsider, many companies stress their preference for home-grown talent. For example, Prologis proudly announces that “All current executive officers were developed, retained and promoted from within.” Spire explains that the board believes internal candidates for executive positions should be “regularly identified” and “developed for consideration.” AIG extends this philosophy beyond the C-suite by providing professional development training and resources for employees at all levels, and notes that 38% of the company’s open positions were filled internally in 2025. 

CEO and management succession planning
Other key governance policies and practices
Talent development

Contribution to recent transitions

Several companies that have recently gone through leadership transitions explained how they amplified their foundational succession planning to fill specific roles. Johnson Controls and AIG both describe how the CEO’s retirement announcement triggered a comprehensive effort to identify a replacement. Lumen notes that the board’s “proactive approach” to succession planning contributed to a dozen successful leadership transitions in the past few years. Walmart and CSX also tout seamless CEO transitions as evidence that their approach to succession planning is effective. 

Board oversight of talent and succession planning
CEO succession planning
CEO and executive succession planning
Corporate governance Management development and succession planning
Board of directors role in succession planning

Succession planning attracts shareholder interest

At the same time companies are expanding their written disclosures to address succession planning, they also are increasingly focusing on the topic in shareholder engagement meetings. Recent proxies for AllState, Prologis, and Oracle all indicate that shareholders wanted to discuss the company’s approach to succession planning. At companies like Broadcom, Conagra, and Goldman Sachs, investor interest was piqued by grants of special retention awards to key executives. In particular, though investors at each of those companies seem to have understood the desire to retain particular officers, they also wanted to hear how the board was planning to replace people who currently seem irreplaceable.

Shareholder engagement
Stockholder outreach highlights
Corporate governance what we heard and the boards response
Stockholder engagement
Shareholder engagement and responsiveness
Use of one time awards

Importance of compensation and culture

Several companies explain how company culture, their compensation program, or both help them retain valuable employees and buttress their succession planning. For example, Chevron, Blackrock, and American Express all link succession planning with the board’s oversight of culture and talent development. Prologis, Walmart, and Blackrock all discuss how their compensation programs support succession planning.

Human capital management
Our board is deeply engaged in understanding the culture of blackrock
How our board engages in ongoing ceo and key executive succession planning
2025 outperformance compensation
What factors does the CMDC consider when setting executive pay
Our executive compensation program and mechanics

Miscellaneous mentions

To reinforce the importance a company places on succession planning, several proxies mention the subject in unexpected places. AllState and Abbvie both mention succession planning experience in director biographies. At Goldman Sachs, succession planning is one of the topics covered during annual board and committee self-evaluations. And at Abbott and Blackrock, a portion of each NEO’s annual incentive award is tied to the executive’s contributions in the area of leadership development and succession planning. 

Richard hume margaret keane
Thomas falk
Board and commitee evaluations
Named executive officer compensation decisions
Pay for performance highlights

Thoughts for your next proxy

Increased investor interest in succession planning may call for increased proxy disclosure. If your board has a formal process for identifying, evaluating, and developing internal candidates, consider describing it. If some of your directors have valuable experience in this area, make sure their biographies include that information. If your investor engagement meetings have touched on the topic, summarize the conversations. And if you have had successful internal leadership transitions because of the board’s initiatives, make sure your proxy reflects that fact. 

PARTAGER :
logo r1
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.